How we rank
Three tables, three units — one rule: rank by the unit price a household actually pays over time, never by the box price.
Fridge water filters: cost per gallon
Every cartridge in a family is rated against the genuine family's rated capacity (for example 200 gallons for an everydrop Filter 4, 300 for a GE MWF, 125 for a Frigidaire EPTWFU01), even when a copy claims a different capacity. That keeps copies honest and comparable. Cost per year assumes the standard 6-month cycle: 2 filters a year.
Certification tiers
A cheap copy is not automatically a good buy. Listings are grouped into tiers read from NSF, IAPMO and WQA certification listings — not from Amazon marketing text:
Certified for lead — certified to NSF/ANSI 53 (or equivalent) for lead reduction. Taste & odor only — certified to NSF/ANSI 42 only. Cert not checked — no listing found yet; the tier is shown as unchecked rather than guessed.
Some families (Bosch UltraClarity Pro in the current data) have no copy certified for lead at all. On those pages we say so, and the genuine filter is the certified recommendation.
Chip filters
GE XWFE/RPWFE and some Samsung cartridges use an RFID chip or authentication tag. A chipless copy can be cheaper and still not run in a fridge that requires the chip. Chipped families are flagged on their pages.
HVAC filters: cost per filter and per year
Ranked within size and MERV. Cost per year uses the normal interval for the depth: 90 days for 1-inch filters, about 12 months for 4-5 inch media filters. Filtrete products carry 3M's own MPR rating; where the maker states a MERV equivalent we show both.
Humidifier filters: estimated cost per year
Wick life depends on water hardness and hours of use, so per-year figures use each maker's stated interval and are labelled estimates.
Prices
The ranking price is always the one-time purchase price. Subscribe & Save prices are never used for ranking, because they require a subscription commitment. Prices refresh from Amazon product data; the check date is printed on every page. When a listing disappears or its pack size changes, it is re-checked before it stays in a table.